When it comes to upgrading your cycling experience, few things make as immediate and lasting an impact as the right pair of cycling shoes. As a chiropractor and professional bike fitter at Forward Chiropractic in Melbourne, I’ve seen first hand how poor shoe choices can lead to pain, inefficiency, and even injury. On the flip side, a well-chosen shoe—paired with the right insoles and a proper bike fit—can improve your comfort, power output, and enjoyment on the bike.

Let’s take a look at what to consider when purchasing cycling shoes, and why they matter more than you might think.

Why Cycling Shoes Matter

Unlike casual footwear, cycling shoes are designed to transfer power directly from your legs to the pedals with minimal loss of energy. But it's not just about stiffness and power—comfort, foot stability, and long-term joint health are all influenced by your choice of shoe.

Ill-fitting shoes can contribute to issues like:

• Numbness or tingling in the toes
• Achilles or plantar fascia strain
• Knee tracking problems
• Hot spots under the forefoot
• General discomfort on longer rides

And that’s just scratching the surface.

Key Features to Look For in a Cycling Shoe

From a bike fitter’s perspective, here’s what you want to look for:

1. Fit Over Brand

Forget marketing hype. The best cycling shoe is the one that fits your foot shape. Pay attention to width, arch support, and overall volume. Some brands run narrow, others accommodate wider feet—so trying on a few models is worth the time.

2. Stiff Sole

A stiff sole (usually made from carbon or composite materials) helps transfer energy more efficiently to the pedals. But stiffness needs to be balanced with comfort—too stiff, and your feet might go numb; too flexible, and you lose performance.

3. Secure Closure System

Look for BOA dials, velcro straps, or ratchet buckles that offer micro-adjustments. The goal is a snug, evenly distributed fit without pressure points.

4. Ventilation

Especially important in Australian summers, breathability helps keep your feet cool and dry.

Recommended Brands

Here are a few shoe brands I consistently see work well for riders during bike fits:

• Lake – Known for their wide range of fit options, including wide and extra-wide widths. Ideal for riders with broader feet.
• Shimano – Great all-rounder with solid construction and sizing consistency. Their high-end models (like the RC9) offer excellent power transfer.
• Specialized – Well-regarded for their Body Geometry design, which offers built-in arch support and metatarsal buttons.
• Bont – Australian-made, with a super stiff sole and heat-moldable upper for a customised fit. Best for performance-focused riders with specific fit needs.

The Role of Cycling Insoles

Even the best cycling shoe can fall short if the insole isn’t supporting your foot correctly. Stock insoles are often flat and generic, which doesn’t account for the unique contours of your arch or the way your foot moves during a pedal stroke.

Upgrading to cycling-specific insoles—such as those from Bontrager/Trek Superfeet insoles, G8 Performance, or Solestar—can improve stability, reduce pressure points, and help align your foot, knee, and hip for a more efficient pedal stroke. In some cases, I’ve seen insoles resolve chronic knee or foot pain that riders thought was just part of cycling.

Why a Bike Fit Matters More Than the Shoe Alone

Your shoes are just one part of a much bigger equation. A proper bike fit ensures that your cleat position, saddle height, and overall bike geometry complement your body and riding style. Even a top-end shoe can cause problems if your cleats are off by just a few millimetres.

At Forward Chiropractic, I start by assessing foot and leg mechanics to determine optimal cleat placement, which affects how power is transferred and how the joints align during pedaling. This is also where custom insoles and shoe adjustments come into play.

Final Thoughts

Investing in the right cycling shoes isn’t just about performance—it’s about comfort, injury prevention, and maximising your time on the bike. Pairing quality shoes with supportive insoles and a professional bike fit ensures that every pedal stroke works for you, not against you.

If you're unsure where to start, or you’re struggling with foot discomfort, book a bike fit session at Forward Chiropractic. We’ll assess your shoes, cleat position, foot mechanics and more to make sure your setup is dialled in for long-term comfort and performance.

‍

Need help choosing the right cycling shoes?
Let us assess your fit, foot support, and cleat position to optimise your ride.